Ikaros family zinc finger 1 regulates dendritic cell development and function in humans


IKZF1 is a key regulator of haematopoiesis and a critical factor in murine lymphocyte development and function21. Normal IKZF1 protein levels are also necessary for the development of IFN-α-producing pDC in mice22,23. Recent descriptions of human IKZF1 haploinsufficiency have confirmed its role in human lymphocyte biology but human DC development has not been studied25,26,27. In this study we analysed blood monocytes and DCs from patients ex vivo carrying heterozygous IKZF1 mutations, or treated with lenalidomide, an IKZF1-depleting immunomodulatory drug. We also probed the effects of IKZF1 deficiency on human DC development and function in vitro.

In keeping with the pleiotropic actions of haematopoietic TFs, IKZF1 deficiency resulted in multi-lineage developmental and functional defects. In addition to the previously described progressive loss of B cells and skewing of T-cell subsets, we found deficiency of pDCs and non-classical monocytes but expansion of cDC1s. Classical monocytes and cDC2 remained numerically unaffected. The near universal finding of this antigen presenting cell phenotype, independent of age, lymphocyte phenotype or clinical status, provides a cellular signature of human IKZF1 mutation. The quantitative changes were remarkably similar in all individuals with missense proteins (families B and C), or truncated protein (family G27), but less severe in members of family F who carry a heterozygous, 11-gene deletion of chromosome 7. In homodimeric proteins, it has been proposed that a heterozygous missense mutation may result in a more severe phenotype than a null allele due to the lower proportion of WT/WT dimers (25% versus 50%, respectively)32. However, in the case of family F, a compensatory effect due to the loss of additional genes cannot be excluded.

The requirement for IKZF1 in human pDC development and function mirrors that seen in the mouse and was supported by its high level of expression in healthy control pDCs. There was no significant increase in absolute number or proportion of cDC1 in mice carrying the heterozygous Ikzf1 L allele, tested in cohorts of 3 animals22, representing either a species or mutation-specific difference. Targets of IKZF1, identified by chromatin immunoprecipitation sequencing33, include ID2, suppression of which is necessary for pDC development and BATF3, required for cDC1 terminal differentiation. De-repression of these loci due to IKZF1 deficiency is consistent with the observed phenotype of absent pDCs but preserved or expanded cDC1s.

The reduction in non-classical monocytes, to our knowledge, has not been reported in Ikzf1-deficient mice. This finding was independent of therapeutic interventions including intravenous immunoglobulin and corticosteroid treatment, previously reported to result in transient depletion of CD16+ monocytes34. Ly6Clow murine monocytes, corresponding to human CD16+ non-classical monocytes, convert from classical monocytes under the control of NOTCH2 signalling stimulated by endothelial cell notch-ligand delta-like 1 (DLL1)35. The role of notch signalling in the generation of CD16+ classical monocytes is untested, but it is known that the regulation of notch target genes is IKZF1 dependent in human T cells36.

The cell-intrinsic effect of IKZF1 mutation on DC phenotype was confirmed in patients receiving therapeutic lenalidomide, known to target IKZF1 for proteosomal degradation28,29.

Varying lenalidomide dose schedules resulted in a range of IKZF1 levels in vivo, revealing a linear relationship between IKZF1 protein and the frequency of pDCs. Such an in vivo dose-response effect would be difficult to demonstrate from the series of germline mutations that confer idiosyncratic, allele-specific effects upon protein structure and function. Parallel observations on the in vitro generation of DCs from primary bone marrow progenitors showed a lenalidomide dose-dependent decrease in the production of pDCs and increase in cDC1s. Although the increased ratio of cDC1 to pDCs was strikingly similar in the ex vivo analysis of patients with germline IKZF1 mutation and those treated with lenalidomide, cDC1s were not expanded and cDC2s were reduced by the drug. This may be due to the known myelosuppressive effect of lenalidomide as concentrations above the therapeutic Cmax of lenalidomide resulted in a reduction in the cellular output per input progenitor cell in vitro. In addition, cereblon-dependent suppression of IRF4 by lenalidomide37 may contribute to the dose-dependent reduction in cDC2 seen in vivo and in vitro. While our data are unable to exclude an effect of IKZF3 deficiency on the DC phenotype in lenalidomide treatment, it is expressed at a much lower level than IKZF1 in human DCs and a role for this factor in DC differentiation has not been described in murine models.

In functional terms, IKZF1 haploinsufficiency resulted in perturbed cell-specific cytokine secretory responses to TLR agonists. Remaining pDCs were unable to secrete IFN-α, production of IL-12 by cDCs was reduced and all cells failed to elaborate as much TNF. A similar pattern was seen in healthy donor DCs exposed to lenalidomide. The reduction in IL-12 secretion contrasted with reports showing that lenalidomide does not compromise IL-12 production from monocyte-derived DCs (moDCs) stimulated with CD40L38,39. However, moDCs are not dependent on IKZF1 for development40 and in vitro stimulation with CD40L triggers IL-12 production through the non-canonical, nuclear factor (NF)-κB (p52/p100) pathway.

Our data are consistent with a direct effect of IKZF1 deficiency upon canonical NF-κB (Rel-A/p50) signalling in which IKZF1 is necessary for the upregulation of Rel-A41 and is itself upregulated by LPS-TLR4 stimulation42. We considered the additional scenario that down regulation of IL-12 might have been an indirect effect of loss of type I IFN production by pDCs, as exogenous IFN augmented IL-12 production43. However, CD303/CD304 ligation, which also abrogates IFN-α, failed to reduce IL-12 production and lenalidomide resulted in a similar reduction in IL-12, despite only a modest fall in IFN-α. From these observations we conclude that lower IL-12 production by cDCs was most likely intrinsic to loss of IKZF1.

The multi-lineage and multi-level influence exerted by haematopoietic TFs complicates the attribution of immunodeficiency resulting from TF mutation to defects in specific immune cell types. In DC deficiency states, the functional diversity of DCs, their combined roles in innate and adaptive immunity and their potential to both activate and tolerise add further complexity. In summarising the consequences of IKZF1 deficiency, pDC dysfunction is likely to play a role. An increased risk of bacterial infection, particularly respiratory infection in the context of germline haploinsufficiency, is consistent with the role of pDC in prompt bacterial clearance and limitation of inflammation in the lung44, in addition to their known anti-viral properties. Humoral immune responses are also dependent upon pDC function through the promotion of naive and memory B-cell proliferation, plasma cell differentiation and immunoglobulin secretion45. This is in keeping with a contribution of pDC deficiency to progressive hypogammaglobulinaemia seen in IKZF1 haploinsufficiency, despite the persistence of plasma cells in tissues25. In other settings, pDCs promote peripheral and central tolerance, through induction of natural and induced regulatory T cells and direct suppression of T-cell responses46. Related to their tolerogenic role, pDCs in the bone marrow microenvironment have been shown to support multiple myeloma cell growth and mediate myeloma-associated immunodeficiency47. The loss of pDCs may therefore promote the development of autoimmunity in IKZF1 haploinsufficiency and confer therapeutic benefit in the treatment of multiple myeloma. These effects are potentially enhanced by an increase in the cDC1/pDC ratio. cDC1s, specialised for cross-presentation of antigen to cytotoxic T cells, are the most potent DCs in immunity to tumours and vaccinations. Consistent with this, in the murine model of multiple myeloma, lenalidomide synergistically enhances the anti-tumour effect of DC vaccines48 and in myeloma patients, lenalidomide enhances responses to a pneumococcal vaccine49.

Finally, IKZF1 and pDC are connected in a number of other conditions. IKZF1 is a susceptibility locus in systemic lupus erythematosus, notable for a type I IFN signature and dysregulated pDC function (reviewed in ref. 50). In BPDCN, frequently involving deletion or loss of function mutations of IKZF1, increased CD56 expression is a hallmark of the neoplastic pDC phenotype24. In the studies described here, increased CD56 expression is seen to arise directly from IKZF1 deficiency.

In summary, our data demonstrate that in addition to its critical role in B-cell differentiation, IKZF1 is required for human pDC development and function. Together with the parallel expansion of cDC1s and reduction of non-classical monocytes, this comprehensively defines the cellular signature of IKZF1 haploinsufficiency. DC dysregulation is highly likely to have pathological consequences for immunity in germline IKZF1 mutation but confer additional therapeutic benefit in lenalidomide treatment of plasma cell dyscrasias. In common with other haematopoietic TFs, germline deficiency reveals multi-level and multi-lineage roles in immune cell development and function with effects in B-cell, T-cell, DC and monocyte lineages.

Source link


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here